Wind, Solar, Water, Diesel: what 's the best mix?


Author
Message
Daria Blackwell
Daria Blackwell
I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)I'm hooked (493 reputation)
Group: Administrators
Posts: 811, Visits: 148
While cruising for several years, we found that one of the most 'lively ' discussion topics among cruisers was, "Which method of generating power works best?" Occasionally, there would be an enthusiastic proponent for one form over another, but more often than not, the discussion was far more complex. I think it might be useful for us to share our experience with different forms of power generation and different equipment options within each category.

So far, we 've learned:

[ul]
[li][/li]
[li][/li]
[/ul]diesel generators are still a very reliable and relatively economical option as long as you can carry enough diesel

[ul]
[li][/li]
[li][/li]
[/ul]solar panels are not as reliable as most would think, especially when the climate tends to be cloudy (Ireland/UK) or days are short (Caribbean) or when parts of the panel are obscured (which can shut the whole panel down)

[ul]
[li][/li]
[li][/li]
[/ul]wind generators tend to be noisy/vibrational and don 't work very well downwind (tradewinds sailing) or in protected anchorages

[ul]
[li][/li]
[li][/li]
[/ul]towed water generators attract BIG fish

That said, we have a diesel generator that works rather flawlessly. Although upon adding AIS, a second navigation system, watermaker, etc, we know we 'll need more power.

We are considering adding a wind generator that can be hoisted into the rigging to catch wind or towed overboard while underway. We are also eagerly awaiting the new generation of solar panels that is supposed to provide a dramatic improvement in efficiency. Does anyone have advice and experience to share that would help us make some decisions on the best gear to add in these departments?

Vice Commodore, OCC 
GO

Merge Selected

Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Threaded View
Threaded View
DariaBlackwell - 20 Jun 2012
robwithers - 22 Jun 2012
DariaBlackwell - 22 Jun 2012
dcaukill - 31 Jul 2012
DariaBlackwell - 31 Jul 2012
gregs - 31 Jul 2012
archive - 22 Aug 2012
DariaBlackwell - 23 Aug 2012
archive - 23 Aug 2012
Blueprintbill - 3 Sep 2012
alshaheen - 5 Oct 2012
mikeaclark - 19 Oct 2012
cverlaque - 23 Oct 2012
jgbailey - 20 Feb 2014
jgbailey - 20 Feb 2014
Blueprintbill - 20 Feb 2014
alshaheen - 21 Feb 2014
Frederic Aujard - 2 Oct 2014
dcaukill - 2 Oct 2014
alshaheen - 2 Oct 2014
Frederic Aujard - 2 Oct 2014
Frederic Aujard - 2 Oct 2014
DariaBlackwell - 2 Oct 2014
simoncurrin - 4 Oct 2014
Frederic Aujard - 4 Oct 2014
AQUALUNA - 21 Oct 2014
simoncurrin - 21 Oct 2014
Dick - 21 Aug 2015
Alex_Blackwell - 21 Aug 2015
alshaheen - 21 Aug 2015
Dick - 21 Aug 2015
Dick - 21 Aug 2015

Login

Search